Is an RRSP Loan Worth It? The Math on Borrowing to Contribute
By Jordan Ellis · Published · Reviewed
Quick Answer
An RRSP loan is worth it only when three conditions hold: your current marginal tax rate clearly beats your expected retirement rate, the refund immediately pays down the loan, and the balance is gone within about 12 months. Borrow $10,000 at 7% for a year and you pay roughly $400 in interest against a refund of about $2,400-$4,300 depending on your bracket — a clear win on paper. Stretched over 5 years, or spent refund, the same move loses to simply contributing monthly.
Every February the banks offer to lend you money to save. Sometimes it’s genuinely smart arithmetic. Here’s how to tell in about two minutes.
The math, one example
Borrow $10,000 at 7%, contribute before the RRSP deadline, deduct against a salary taxed at a 30% marginal rate (roughly a $70,000 income in Ontario):
- Interest over 12 months: ~$400
- Refund: ~$3,000 → applied to the loan the day it arrives
- Remaining loan: $7,000, paid off over the year at about $607/month
- Net: $10,000 compounding inside the RRSP for a total financing cost of ~$400, plus a $3,000 refund that did most of the heavy lifting
That’s the good version. Check what the deduction is worth at your own income with the RRSP vs TFSA calculator.
The three conditions that make it work
- Your bracket today beats your bracket in retirement. Deduct at 38%, withdraw at 22% — that’s the spread the whole RRSP is built on. At a 24% bracket the trade gets thin; see RRSP vs TFSA: which first.
- The refund retires the loan. Not a vacation, not a TV. The refund hitting the loan is what converts leverage into savings.
- Gone within ~12 months. Interest is the enemy of the strategy. At 12 months it costs ~4% of the contribution; stretched to 5 years it costs ~19% and the math flips against you.
When to skip it
- Low-income year. Save the room; contribute when your rate is higher. Room never expires.
- You’d be borrowing for the refund, not the retirement. If the plan for the refund is spending, you’re just financing consumption at 7% with a future tax bill attached.
- Your emergency fund is empty. RRSP withdrawals cost withholding tax and permanently destroy room — our withholding tax guide shows the damage. Liquidity first.
- The loan amortizes past a year. A 5-year RRSP loan is a product designed for the bank’s February targets, not your net worth.
The boring alternative that usually wins
Set an automatic transfer of $835/month into your RRSP starting this month. Same $10,000 a year, zero interest, no deadline, no credit check — and your payroll can even reduce source deductions with a T1213 so the refund arrives every paycheque instead of every spring. Not as exciting as a lump sum. Better in almost every way that compounds.
Official sources
Rules and dollar limits change. Confirm current amounts with the official pages below before you act · Last reviewed .
- Tax rates on RRSP withdrawals (Canada Revenue Agency)
- RRSPs and related plans (Canada Revenue Agency)